An Example of Why Gender Identity Inclusion Is Important

July 3, 2007 ·

An update on the previous post, Trans-panic Defense Alive And Well In Palm Beach.

A 17 year old Florida teen was found guilty of a second-degree felony of aggravated battery when he assaulted a 39 year old transwoman. Further details of the beating were learned when one of the police officers testified.

From the Palm Beach Post:

“Palm Beach police Sgt. Jennifer Sandman, who interviewed the teen on the morning of the incident, testified at Monday’s trial in juvenile court that he seemed arrogant and told her he beat the transsexual until his hand was sore.

He said he left to look for his cellphone in his friend’s car, then returned to beat the 39-year-old again, Sandman said.”

Another witness that was on the beach that night testified that:

“that the teen forced her to kneel in the sand while he punched her and slammed her head into a lifeguard stand where he was sitting. The impact shook the stand, he said.”

While the judge did find him guilty he said he didn’t believe this was a hate crime.

“The teen did not seem to beat the victim because of sexual orientation, but because of his anger and desire for retribution.”

‘Your anger, from your perspective and from many other people’s perspective, may be justifiable anger,” Blanc said. “But the act that you committed in that anger cannot be justified under our existing system of laws.’

and added:

“In many ways it appears from the testimony that was presented here that there are two victims in the case.”

Two victims? I’m glad the judge ruled appropriately, but his comments after the fact seem to indicate sympathy for the accused.

Next Post

Give A Big Welcome

Everyone give a big warm welcome to our newest blogger, Jenn Burleton.  She blogs here.
Read
Previous Post

With This Ring, I Thee Wed

More and more proof that the wing nuts are wrong. "Gender Identity Disorders and Bipolar Disorder Associated With the Ring Y Chromosome"
Read
Random Post

The Curious Demands of the Womyn in the Woods: Unpacking the Statement of the Michigan Womyn’s Musical Festival

The Demands of Michfest's Lisa Vogel: A Response & a Good Faith Offer of Support By Emmagene Cronin   The end of the 39th annual Michigan Womyn’s Music Festival (MWMF of Michfest) has arrived, and the trans community has been…
Read
Random Post

Fight back: Report Mississippi & North Carolina HATE here!

By Autumn Sandeen & Cristan Williams Anti-trans activists in both Mississippi and North Carolina have passed laws that effectively remove trans people from public life. Making it legal on a state level to discriminate against trans people in employment, housing, goods, and…
Read
Random Post

COVID-19: Support Trans People

The Trans Disaster Relief Fund (TDRF) sent out an urgent request for donations to support transgender individuals and other members of the LGBTQI+ community during the current Coronavirus emergency. The transgender community is uniquely at risk during this emergency because…
Read
Random Post

Take the Trans “Sense of Community” Survey!

Take the survey here   For some time, I’ve seen and heard subjective assertions like: I love the trans community! I hate the trans community! There is no such thing as a trans community! I wish the trans community was stronger…
Read