#TERFweek: Let’s not repeat our history

August 11, 2014 ·

By Cristan Williams
@cristanwilliams

 

The following article was published in 1974. Note the way the overall public held anti-trans views in contempt. Note the dismissive way the author of this article reported on TERF bigotry. I think this article serves as an important cautionary tale because I can’t help but note that today, like in this 1974 article, some feminists and trans folk seem to think TERF anti-trans dogma is irrelevant.

Please never forget the damage they’ve caused. They are as hubris as they are cruel; TERFs have repeatedly shown that they take perverse pleasure in increasing the level of suffering within the trans population.  The harm TERFs went on to inflict upon the trans community after this article was published is arguably without parallel.

BEBE INFILTRATES FEMINIST CONFERENCE

At a recent feminist conference, drag queen Bebe J. Scarpie successfully was able to infiltrate the question line, from which men were excluded, in order to challenge Jill Johnston, the radicalesbian columnist. Miss Johnston, is primarily noted for a recent letter to the National Organization of Women, in which she proposed that mothers neglect to care for male babies. She also attacked drag actress Holly Woodlawn, when the latter was making a public appearance. At this conference she wanted to allow only those males necessary for artificial insemination to exist. Bebe accused Jill of being a Neo-fascist and dictating to women as well as men. At this point however, a radicalesbian recognized her from previous encounters, and screamed out, “Jill don’t answer, it’s a male question.” The audience, composed 50% of college students and 50% of Jill’s entourage, was left in total amazement. It was interesting since with their close cropped hair and full denim outfits, the radical women were more transvestites than Bebe!

Finally one of the straight women present picked up Behe’s line of questioning. Jill again demonstrated an inability to build any logic sequence of thoughts and she succeeded in boring half the college students into leaving while she was trying to explain that sleeping with a male made a woman a male, to which this straight sister replied then it made her boyfriend a woman.

It was overheard by one of Babe’s friends that the radical panel had muttered that they couldn’t believe this was happening to them. Drag Power!

Some who may not be aware of the painful history that the TERF movement has inspired might be tempted to, as we’ve done in the past, think that TERFs are simply an irrelevant group of logically-incoherent trolls. They, like the author of this 1974 article, might find comfort in believing that this fundamentalist group won’t be able to do anything to actually affect the lives of real people.

It was a denial-based indifference that allowed the TERF movement to harm so many in the past and it is my hope that over the course of #TERFweek, some of the denial the TERF movement needs to ensure that TERF ideology can be unquestioningly promoted within academia and media outlets might be dispelled.

JR-TransHistory

Transgender History by Susan Stryker, page 110


NOTE:

The nuances of language have come a long way since 1974. The different and nuanced ways of understanding trans identities were only just beginning to be discussed within the trans community itself. Additionally, in 1974 and the TERF colonization of the RadFem identity had already begun. This was only a year after a Radical Feminist was beaten by TERFs for attempting to protect the physical safety of a trans woman at the 1973 West Coast Lesbian Conference. It wasn’t until 2008 that the feminist community created the term “TERF” as a means of distinguishing between a a movement hyper-focused on oppressing trans people and the actual feminist/Radical Feminist movement.



Tip this TransAdvocate!

Writers for the TransAdvocate work hard to bring you news and commentary. If you found this article meaningful, let the author know that you appreciate the work they do with a tip!

Next Post

#TERFweek: Remember Filisa Vistima

Before you read further, I need to state a strong Trigger Warning: The following post recounts the circumstances surrounding the suicide of a trans women. Filisa Vistima was a 22-year-old transsexual woman from Seattle who had not been able to access the…
Read
Previous Post

Quit attacking your allies!

I have seen various version of this phrase. "Quit attacking your allies!" - many, many times.  I've only been involved heavily in trans activism for about two years.  How and why I've become as invested as I am is a…
Read
Random Post

TLC's Masen Davis: What Happens Next With AB 1266

A brief video filmed in early November, 2013, with Masen Davis of the Transgender Law Center. In this video he discusses what we can expect in the next few days regarding AB 1216: the School Success and Opportunity Act. For…
Read
Random Post

ENDA Bill Introduced... Last Week?

Today at 1pm today (6-24-09) Barney Frank is set to officially introduce the HR 2981, The Employment Non-Discrimination Act. This week, Congressman Barney Frank will introduce the Employee Non-Discrimination Act.  The legislation would extend federal employment laws, which currently prevent…
Read
Random Post

The Hate We Fight Abroad, The Ignorance At Home

In the context of the "war" for our equality, trans-people have to fight the war on two fronts. There's the kind of hatred that is espoused by morally corrupt people on the right wing conservative side (the "abroad" part of…
Read
Random Post

African Voices: Well behaved women rarely make history

Well behaved women rarely make history: A Botswana transgender woman made history after filling a monumental constitutional case against the government for refusing to legally change her gender marker. By Miles Tanhira In her High court application against the department of…
Read