Protest, HRC, and My Investment Portfolio

February 14, 2008 ·

I like to think of my advocacy/political work in much of the same way as I think of how to invest my money. I see activism as an investment in my community and my future. With that in mind, I have to say that I don’t see the benefit in protesting the Human Rights Campaign (HRC). There are so many national organizations that support transgender people and support gender identity in ENDA (National Stonewall Democrats, National Gay and Lesbian Task Force and Pride At Work, for example), I think it’s a waste of time to try and get an organization to love us, that has shown repeatedly that it doesn’t.

Protests do have their place. I totally supported the HRC/Nancy Pelosi Dinner protest because ENDA was pending in the House. The media exposure could have had an effect on the outcome of the legislation. But I don’t see the same result from these kind of protests/boycotts.

The best thing transgender people can do to move legislation forward is to be diverse in their activism, and support those who support gender identity inclusion. Instead of buying 100% percent of HRC stock, DIVERSIFY, DIVERSIFY, DIVERSIFY!

Speaking of support, according to PageOneQ, Barney Frank is going to be on the Michealangelo Signorile Show to respond to Matt Foreman’s comment that Barney Frank “has always been pretty squeamish on the trans issue.”

It’ll be interesting to hear what he has to say. Frank’s “penises in showers” outburst in 2000 is legendary in transactivist circles.

Regardless, it’ll be interesting to listen to. Frank and the Human Rights Campaign are in an odd position. Two out of three possible candidates for President of the United States support inclusion of gender identity in ENDA, but the most senior gay House member doesn’t.

In category:Politics
Next Post

Back to Oz

I really do hesitate to even write this post, as the topic is a rehash of one of the ugliest times for GLBT unity I've ever seen. Recently Matt Foreman said the following on the Michelangelo Signorile Show concerning the…
Read
Previous Post

HRC3 ≠ Bright Future For Transgenders

“This is a story of the lives and loves, and hopes and dreams, of young Batswana in the context of the changing cultural norms and values of modern times. Each of the dancers are shaped and challenged by the forces…
Read
Random Post

Not A Feminist By Birth Or Biology

I've been over at Feministing all day, writing responses to "You learn something new every day." The post is a response to The BBC's recent coverage of a debate with Julie Bindel. Julie believes that sex reassignment surgery is a…
Read
Random Post

Standing in the Light

“Oh,” was my mother’s response when I explained why we aren’t coming to Thanksgiving dinner at her house. “No one else will be here. Everyone else is going to another house,” she compromised. In her mind I’m sure she thought…
Read
Random Post

Presidential Forum on Marriage Equality

It was billed as the "HRC Foundation and Logo Presidential Forum" but you could have just as easily called it the "HRC and Logo Presidential Forum on Marriage Equality. But it wasn't supposed to be that way. According to Donna…
Read
Random Post

Why is Free State Just Us, er..., 'Equality' Maryland Afraid to Have its Propaganda Critiqued in the Light of Day?

CENSORED AGAIN!!!!!!!!!!! And, of course, the sockpuppet's sockpuppet is right in the middle of it. That was the second comment to the following post at PHB: Valentine's Day in Maryland is about more than dinner and roses this year The…
Read
  1. Strange – my pooter missed a bit! The post after the 🙂 should read, “LOL@ Pick your poison.” Here’s a few more to add to the list . . .

  2. Strange – my pooter missed a bit! The post after the 🙂 should read, “LOL@ Pick you poison.” Here’s a few more to add to the list . . .

  3. Wise words, Monica. 🙂 trans issues involving young people, sex workers, ethnic minorities, senior citizens, equal opportunities policies, prisons, the world!

  4. We have to be careful about putting all our activism efforts into one and only one “basket.” Protests, EIs, letter writing, E-mails, phone calls, office visits, townhalls, political fund raisers, political conventions, political parties, vigils, homeless shelters, HIV/AIDS activism, breast cancer prevention, support groups, veterans issues, locals equality groups, trans political groups, churches, etc, etc, etc.

    I’m not suggesting you get involved with all of these, but you can work on some of these part of a time and some of these other times. Pick your poison. We can use all of you spread everywhere. I say to any of you who do even one of these things, “Thank you so very much.”

  5. I have to agree with with the Bear of the Artic – diversification includes protesting those who work to keep you out of civil rights legislation. Especially when they’re presenting themselves to elected officials as THE voice on these issues. Many of those officials don’t know about this exclusion till told – and many people attending those dinners – that’s the only thing they do all year. Lot’s of people find out what their money is going to support because people make the effort to tell them at that dinner.

    It’s also a bit sweet to have elected officials tell HRC that they’re on the wrong side of the civil rights debate at their own event. Some even asked – should I not go to the dinner?

    You challenge discrimination everywhere.

  6. I do support protests and EIs against HRC, since, by their actions, they stand in our way. But, as Marti states, we should be diverse in our advocacy. Protest HRC if you have time to, and it’s close – there are many good reasons why they’re bad for the entire GLBT community – the money they steal from state and local orgs with their massive galas (that rarely comes back to your community)is a good start. However, when you’re not protesting, be sure you’re taking care of advocacy business in DC, your state capitol, and your city hall. And support organizations that support your work. Support politicians that support us.

  7. Wow, I am shocked. I’m not sure what discussion that comment is referring to, but I’m fairly glad Leigh is done here. I didn’t think this dialogue was particularly useful to continue participating in, but I didn’t realize it was becoming dangerous.

    I mean, usually racist comments are vieled and comparisons to nazis are left to unjustified hyperbole. I’ve only encountered one or two people who actually claim the nazis had the right idea.

    *sigh*

    Calls to genocidal extermination of folks who aren’t white anglo saxon… I never thought I’d see something like that on a trans blog.

  8. I don’t think HRC or the folks who go to an HRC dinner need educated, so no I don’t support them. I know I’m in the minority on that though.

  9. Do you support Educational Initiatives? They are not protests, but a chance to educate the people who support HRC on the needs of the transgender community by going to events where HRC supporters hange out, like their dinners. There will be one at Charlotte, NC this weekend and there have been one in Austin and Phillie so far.