What’s More Unfair?

August 14, 2005 ·

When a middle school teacher leaves for the summer as he and plans to return as she, is it unfair to students? More or less unfair than it would be to re-assign the teacher?

Ms. McCaffrey is the teacher I’m speaking of. She’s been teaching for twelve years and had her surgery in February, after which she returned to school in a jacket and tie to not cause a commotion.

McCaffrey has chosen to wait for the summer to share the news of her surgery with students and parents so they may have more time to come to terms with everything.

As for whether or not she will be re-assigned in September, Janie Edmunds, the district’s superintendent of schools, would not comment.

The one thing I’m sure of: Ms. McCaffrey shouldn’t have to wait and wonder. Schools need to take a stance on trans issues and be clear, during the hiring process, about what will happen when a teacher or any employee transitions.

Should you hear any updated news, please share it with us!

In category:Opinion
Next Post

Open Letter to Windows Media

By Autumn Sandeen Dear Windows Media Management, I find it difficult to believe that Windows Media truly believes "Newspapers should reflect all aspects of their readers' lives" and that its "superior editorial content and community involvement sets apart". Although your…
Read
Previous Post

Where is the Transgender Martin Luther King Jr.?

By Autumn Sandeen All quotes in italics are the words of Martin Luther King Jr. "Cowardice asks the question - is it safe? Expediency asks the question - is it politic? Vanity asks the question - is it popular? But…
Read
Random Post

Gender Nation: Trans prisoners, the next battleground

Gender Nation is a bi-weekly column by Gwendolyn Ann Smith, the founder of the Transgender Day of Remembrance, reviewing news affecting the trans, intersex, and genderqueer community. Trans prisoners, the next battleground A federal court case represented by the Alliance Defending…
Read
Random Post

Transgender Pathologization

By Kat Haché @papierhache NOTE: Content warning below. Yesterday, I came across an article in the LA Times regarding the National Transgender Discrimination Survey’s study of the elevated risk of suicide in the transgender community.  To briefly summarize, the statistics are shocking:…
Read
Random Post

So...The Marriage Derangement Syndrome-Oids Don't Have To Take Responsibility For Anything?

From Joe at The John's site: Opponents of same-sex marriage have created a three-pronged effort that insures the issue will be a key topic in the Presidential election. There are efforts underway by Republicans legislators in Iowa, the first caucus…
Read
Random Post

On Trial in Texas: The Transitioned Status of Trans People

Me & Judge Frye Today Phyllis Frye (America's first out trans judge) and I met up with Nikki Araguz at the 13th District Court of Appeals for the hearing on how Texas will view the transitioned status of trans folk.…
Read
  1. I’ve been in contact with Kerry McCaffrey and although she’s been under extraordinary stress, she seems to be fine. Her school and employer has been supportive as well as most of her neighbors. She has a number of local trans friends that appear to give her support.

    We got a couple of letters published in the major daily that were very positive (including mine),that clearly seemed to overwhelm the couple of obtuse negative public comments. Even though she lives in a bastion of conservative Republicans, I’ve heard nothing from her homophobic neocon legislators.

    they wouldn’t dare! We’d embarrass the hell out of them! The state of New Jersey has quietly added Gender Identity or Expression to their EEO policy for state employees, including colleges. the public announcement of this should be timed just as our legislation is vented in committee!

    We are almost there!

  2. I’ve been in contact with Kerry McCaffrey and although she’s been under extraordinary stress, she seems to be fine. Her school and employer has been supportive as well as most of her neighbors. She has a number of local trans friends that appear to give her support.

    We got a couple of letters published in the major daily that were very positive (including mine),that clearly seemed to overwhelm the couple of obtuse negative public comments. Even though she lives in a bastion of conservative Republicans, I’ve heard nothing from her homophobic neocon legislators.

    they wouldn’t dare! We’d embarrass the hell out of them! The state of New Jersey has quietly added Gender Identity or Expression to their EEO policy for state employees, including colleges. the public announcement of this should be timed just as our legislation is vented in committee!

    We are almost there!