Transphobic Jokes, Context, and the Free Speech Canard

July 11, 2015 ·

Recently comedian Vicky Wagner posted this on social media:

11709546_10207389269635678_2053401675138947214_nWhen criticized, she said:

“I appreciate your opinion but Caitlyn had 65 years exp being a man in a man’s world. She had male privilege. Has nothing to do with respect. Has to do with jokes. No one is off limits and I can’t censor my self. Expected some flak. We should be able to laugh at ourselves. I have plenty of Gay and Lesbian jokes so why are Trans offlimits?
Late Night Jokes.”

and on her Facebook page says:

“Lenny Bruce, the infamous comedian, went through a lot to say what he wanted to say and in doing so helped pave the way for the rest of us comedians and uphold that Freedom of Speech thing in the Constitution……. #‎wontbecensored‬.”

It would seem that Wagner doesn’t know what censorship is. From Patheos:

Free speech is the right to speak your mind without government censorship and without fear of extralegal retaliation like harassment or violence. That’s all!

Free speech doesn’t include the right to speak your mind on any forum anywhere. The government may not prevent you from speaking, but private parties, like blog owners or corporations, aren’t required to let you use their property as your platform.

Free speech doesn’t include the right to be believed or to be taken seriously. People may mock, ridicule or laugh at what you say, or they may reject it outright.

Free speech doesn’t include the right to be listened to. People who don’t desire to hear your opinion can hang up on you, block you on social media, change the channel, close the browser tab. Free speech doesn’t give you the right to bombard people with harassing messages or otherwise force them to pay attention to you against their will.

And free speech doesn’t include the right to suffer no consequences whatsoever for your expressed opinions. As Facebook found out, if you say things that other people find abhorrent, they may boycott you, disinvite you or choose not to associate with you.

This is especially true in terms of comedy. As Michael Richards found out, a white comedian uttering racial slurs will severely hamper or end a career.

That’s why I asked Wagner on Facebook:

“Vicki Wagner what was the last black joke you told? Jewish joke? Please do let us know your favourites that you tell, because you don’t ‘self censor.'”

When it comes to comedy and racial jokes, context matters. Chris Rock can use of N-word because he’s African American. Marc Maron can make jokes about Jewish people because he’s Jewish. Wagner is a cis white lesbian. Wagner states “we should be able to laugh at ourselves,” but unless Wagner is trans, she isn’t laughing at “ourselves” but laughing at “them.” Trans people should be “off limits” for her the same reason white comedians making black jokes are off limits.

Beyond that, it’s really just pathetic to make fun of a vulnerable minority. For many visibly trans people (like myself), we’re already the butt of jokes daily. In the realm of comedy, it’s low hanging (cruel) fruit.

Wagner has the right to be offensive, but people have the right to be offended by her comedy. If Wagner continues with this kind of transphobic humor, history will more than likely think as an Archie Bunker/Andrew Dice Clay archetype rather than Lenny Bruce.

Next Post

The Look, Interrupted: How Cinema Looks At Trans Women's Bodies

In the 2013 film Adult World, when cisgender protagonist Amy is cleaning the bathroom, she peers through a glory hole in the stall to see Rubia, a transgender woman, using the urinal. The sequence is constructed around Amy's point-of-view: Adult…
Read
Previous Post

Psychiatric abuse of transgender people: a case from Russia

The reality of trans pathologization in Russia By Yana Kirey-Sitnikova Note: The article contains descriptions of violence and involuntary medical treatment. Psychiatric treatment of transgender people has recently received attention in media and medical literature in response to strong international campaigns…
Read
Random Post

How TERF violence inspired Camp Trans

In the middle of a cool August night in 1991, Nancy Burkholder was thrown out of the Michigan Womyn's Music Festival (MWMF) because she’s a trans woman.  Burkholder was Janis Walworth’s friend and she was outraged that MWMF’s would engage…
Read
Random Post

Am I A Woman Born Transsexual?: The Politics of Trans-Identities

The intersection of internet wars sometimes brings interesting observations to mind, and today one such intersection really spoke to me. Recently Jasper over at Jasper's wardrobe has made some pretty controversial things about gender and transwomen. From "just your average…
Read
Random Post

Many Quotes About AB 1266

I've collected a number of quotes from those against California's School Success and Opportunity Act (AB 1266) referendum signature drive and should it turn out to be successful. There's also some background quotes by some of the characters or organizations…
Read
Random Post

Press Release from TransMaryland Concerning HB235

Press release from TransMaryland: TransMaryland Issues Statement of HB235’s Demise Maryland House Bill Ultimately Failed on Several Levels Annapolis — April 12, 2011 — Today is not a day to celebrate, for it is still one more year without the…
Read