Revictimized In Death

April 30, 2013 ·

Image: Cemia Dove

Dehumanization of murdered trans women seems to be the norm these days. No matter how many times GLAAD and trans activists reach out to teach journalists how not to revictimize murdered trans women — especially trans women of color — there always seems to be a “next time.”

A new example of a “next time” is found in John Caniglia‘s two articles for the Cleveland Plain Dealer, entitled Oddly dressed body found in Olmsted Township pond identified and Brutal slaying marks the end of Clevelander’s fight for acceptance — the second listed article with Plain Dealer news researcher Jo Ellen Corrigan. The murder victim was well known by Cemia “Ci Ci” Dove (also having been referred to in blogs and mainstream media as C. Acoff and Ci Ci Acoff), but the Plain Dealer made a point of referring to her by her legal male name.

Monica Roberts has written a couple of pieces on the murder, and she described the Plain Dealer‘s horrible coverage in a checklist of how media revictimizes murdered trans women of color:

  • Misgender the person at every opportunity? Check
  • Use police mugshot? Check
  • Drag old criminal record into the story? Check
  • ‘Deception meme’ injected into story? Check
  • ‘Tragic transsexual’ meme injected into this story? Check
  • Use salacious and sensationalist headlines? Check
  • Not give a rats anus about the victim’s dignity and their femme presentation? Check
  • Disrespecting another African-American transwoman? Check

The articles also focused a great deal about what Cemia was wearing, and how she had a criminal history of petty crimes — including possessing hormones.

For me, the hardest part in reading that first article, Oddly dressed body found in Olmsted Township pond identified, was found in this paragraph (emphasis added)::

Police said after they contacted area law enforcement for help identifying the body, Cleveland detectives told them they had a missing person matching its description.

Yeah. Plain Dealer reporter John Caniglia referred to Cemia as an it.

GLAAD got it right in early April with their blog post GLAAD to Media: Tell the Story of Anti-Transgender Violence Correctly. So depressing that here only a couple of weeks later, the Plain Dealer got this story of a murdered trans woman so wrong.

GLAAD also has a post up entitled GLAAD and local advocates addressing horrific coverage of transgender murder victim that is specific to the horrid coverage of Cemia’s death.

Trans people — hell, every human being — deserves better than this. It’s bad enough that three trans women of color have been murdered this month, but adding disrespectful, revictimization of a brutally murdered trans woman by horrid media coverage is something trans community and trans community allies should not tolerate.

~~~~~
There is a rally for Ci Ci (also apparently spelled Ce Ce) scheduled for May 1st in Clevelend Ohio. Details on the location and time are here.

Next Post

Seven Goals Of Trans Activism

There are whys to transgender activism, but beyond the whys of transgender activism there are the whats: there are the goals of transgender activism. Here are seven goals of trans activism with some explanation as to why these are trans…
Read
Previous Post

Why Transgender Activism

I published an earlier revision of this essay first on January 12, 2011 at Pam's House Blend. I believe the hypothesis of this essay is still true and bears repeating every now and again. ~~A~~ I work on LGBT community…
Read
Random Post

[TW: Blood, Death] Mexico city Transgender Woman thrown off a bridge dies

Hilary Molina Mendiola died September 23rd at 7:30pm after being thrown naked from the Southern Juan Escutia Axis 2 in the Cuauhtemoc borough of Mexico city. Ms. Mendiola had bruises on her face according to Noticias Terra.com. showing signs of a struggle.…
Read
Random Post

Trans medical treatment and faith

A reader writes: I am trans but also religious. Although I live as a woman, I was born with boy parts. In my opinion, to have surgery would imply that God made a mistake. I do not believe that God…
Read
Random Post

This Says It Better Than I Ever Could

From Alas, a blog Amp has been personally attacked many times because of this cartoon. I believe it's because it's speaking truth. Some folks don't like to see their own reflection, or refuse to believe it and react violently when…
Read
Random Post

PJI fundraising video targeting suicidal trans kid goes viral

The Pacific Justice Institute (PJI) is the ex-gay organization that stirred up the right-wing word when it claimed that a trans kid (who I will refer to as Jane Doe, for reasons of safety) in Colorado was harassing cisgender girls in the restrooms. Right wing…
Read