Rapid onset gender dysphoria and other myths

March 11, 2018 ·

The anti-trans movement created a new pathology they’re shopping around to various (mostly right-wing) news outlets. It’s called “rapid onset gender dysphoria” and you catch it from websites like DeviantArt, Tumblr, and Reddit. A great takedown of this internet illness was published by the Advocate and I encourage you to check it out. Having said that, I want to focus on the more obvious, yet overlooked flaws of this concocted condition: it asserts itself to be both “rapid onset” and “gender dysphoria.” Actual gender dysphoria cannot, by the clinical definition of the term be rapid.

Here’s the clinical definition of gender dysphoria:

“… of at least 6 months duration…”

Unless you’re prepared to claim that half a year is “rapid,” by the clinical definition of “gender dysphoria,” it cannot be both “rapid” and gender dysphoria. While I’m sure the irony is unintentional, the main vector for “rapid onset gender dysphoria” is an internet site called Transgender Trend. The group recently released a slick looking booklet full of lies and misinformation targeting schools, teachers, and vulnerable families:

Did you know that there’s a wave of children undergoing “medical gender reassignment treatments”? Neither did I.

The reality is that it’s unethical to give children “medical gender reassignment treatments.” Not only must a child receive a valid DSM-5 gender dysphoria diagnosis to receive clinical care for gender dysphoria, the care provided to children is in the form of psychological support. Even so, for this type of care to be ethical, it must be provided in adherence to the Standards of Care, which bars the types of treatments Transgender Trend claims as being a “new phenomenon.”

Moreover, the “study” Transgender Trend refers to was actually just a mere poster that was hung up at a convention.  The sex essentialists activist who authored the poster asked Transgender Trend comment section commentators and other site supporters if they think cisgender kids are suddenly becoming trans after going to Reddit, YouTube, Tumblr, and DeviantArt. Nevermind the sex essentialists activist “researcher” failed to disclose the source of their data, groups that are sympathetic to the lies Transgender Trend peddles now claims this “study” proves that being trans is something kids catch from the internet.

If this all sounds like you’ve heard this type of rhetoric before, it’s because you have:

Intro to an ex-gay therapist’s “success” story

The ex-gay movement has, for years, claimed that kids are gay because it makes them popular, that they get attention, and/or they were having difficulty forming an identity. The above story states that the kid in question felt they were, “kind of an outcast, really not social with anybody except one person who was very shy like me.” But then comes along the concept of being gay and suddenly, “they were all supportive, like I was a celeb.” Note how this right-wing narrative is found in the very snake oil anti-trans activists are, at this very moment, working to introduce into schools:

 

Transgender Trend Refuses to Debate their fact claims

On March 2nd, the TransAdvocate issued an invitation to debate the various lies Transgender Trend pushes and, as expected, for all their rhetoric about “free speech,” the hate group is ducking debating the various lies they’re currently pushing on schools and vulnerable families. It has been…

933 days 12 hours 52 minutes 18 seconds

… since we challenged Transgender Trend to debate the claims they make in their booklet. The hate group refuses to stand behind the hoax they are, even now, attempting to perpetrate, targeting the most vulnerable among us: gender dysphoric school kids. While we know that supporting trans kids produces better mental health outcomes, hate groups like Transgender Trend seem absolutely fine with sacrificing as many children’s wellbeing if it means getting their ex-gay right-wing ripoff of a disease into the hands of non-medical and non-psychological professionals who hold sway over a child’s well-being.



Tip this TransAdvocate!

Writers for the TransAdvocate work hard to bring you news and commentary. If you found this article meaningful, let the author know that you appreciate the work they do with a tip!

Next Post

Houston GLBT Political Caucus throws trans people under the bus

Unfortunately, it appears that the Houston GLBT Political Caucus, like HRC before them, is throwing the transgender community under the bus. Members of the Caucus Board encouraged candidates in the current election to support and seek the endorsement of the…
Read
Previous Post

Q&A: Taking a break from trans advocacy

The TransAdvocate Q & A is where we answer your questions. If you’d like to submit a question, go to our contact page and send it in. Today’s question is: Is it responsible or okay that I'm taking a hiatus…
Read
Random Post

There’s Something About Transphobia

I'm continually amazed at the hatred and bigotry shown by the Fox Broadcasting Network. The fall lineup includes the inherently transphobic series, "There’s Something About Miriam." The series first aired in the 2004 in the UK and features six men…
Read
Random Post

Do Not Blame Trans People For The Fact That, At Midnight, Maryland Will Have No Statewide Trans Protections

The reason that the Maryland legal status quo of today is trans-free is not the fault of anyone who opposed HB235.  The Maryland legal status quo of today was created by the people who engineered a gay-only rights bill for themselves a…
Read
Random Post

Fact check: study shows transition makes trans people suicidal

A 2011 Swedish study proves that trans people are more suicidal due to transition, are likely rapists and that trans women exhibit male socialization. Or does it? Perhaps you've heard that a Swedish study found that trans people who access medical care…
Read
Random Post

Dylan Forbis: Out Trans Man Running for Texas House!

We've seen out trans people running and winning elections throughout the nation recently and today the TransAdvocate welcomes our guest host Dylan Forbis, an out trans man running for a seat in the Texas House! Subscribe to the TransAdvocate Podcasts…
Read