I’m Trans, and I Don’t Like or Use the Trans Flag

July 5, 2015 ·

Facebook recently came out with a way to “rainbowify” your Facebook icon to show support for the Supreme Court’s ruling on marriage equality. Soon after, a way to “celebrate trans pride” was also released.

Recently a friend of mine, Shadi Petosky, posted on Facebook something that expressed my feelings about the trans flag perfectly:

“I’ll never use the trans flag on my photo or in any context.

It’s anti-feminist, not one flavor of feminism wants to continue codefying baby pink for baby girls and baby blue for baby boys. In a culture where we so many are trying to undo the pink = girl and blue = boys thing it just seem completely regressive and out of touch. As a parent, I work hard against this slow drip of gender as vector oppression, as sex stereotype.

It’s not just pink and blue, it was designed as “baby pink” and “baby blue.” So at any event people literally buy streamers and balloons from the baby section of a party store. It feels infantile.
That’s an association I’d like to leave behind with those colors.

Anti-feminist and infantile. That’s our symbol? I get that people like flags and in the absence of anything else this one soldiers on –“

I tend to agree with this. Your thoughts?

Next Post

Psychiatric abuse of transgender people: a case from Russia

The reality of trans pathologization in Russia By Yana Kirey-Sitnikova Note: The article contains descriptions of violence and involuntary medical treatment. Psychiatric treatment of transgender people has recently received attention in media and medical literature in response to strong international campaigns…
Read
Previous Post

In Case You Missed it, Hillary Clinton Can't Say Transgender

I'm not sure why the Hillary Clinton campaign is sending me their LGBT related emails (I've never solicited this), but it seems as if I've been put on her press list. Today I received this: It's an email from the…
Read
Random Post

The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly?

I spend a lot of time here at The Transadvocate posting various news articles from around the web through a plugin that pulls tweets from the Transadvocate Twitter page. Recently Stephanie Stevens from Abnormal Heights and Transgender News Yahoo group…
Read
Random Post

Arizona Transgender Woman Monica Jones on trial for refusing "Project Rose"

Monica's troubles began one night after protesting Arizona’s failed religious anti-LGBT legislation while walking to a bar. An undercover officer engaged her in a conversation which led to her being charged with "manifesting prostitution”, AKA walking while trans. Since Jones…
Read
Random Post

As If You Needed Any More Proof: Randi Rhodes III

From the Wednesday, July 25th edition of the Randi Rhodes Show When someone apologizes for a "bad joke" and understands their mistake by making the following comment... " This is my second attempt at posting a reply because I feel…
Read
Random Post

HR 1592

HR 1592 IH 110th CONGRESS 1st Session H. R. 1592 To provide Federal assistance to States, local jurisdictions, and Indian tribes to prosecute hate crimes, and for other purposes. IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES March 20, 2007 Mr. CONYERS (for…
Read
  1. Funny, until the past few months, I didn’t even know that we had a flag. My first thought when I saw the flag wasn’t a feminist critique. It was simply, “Oh god. That’s really ugly.”

    I like the rainbow flag because it’s so bright and eye-catching. This flag isn’t. It’s pastel, muted, and bland.

    That’s my 2¢ and probably worth only that.

    People have been asking for an alternative. How about this:
    1) A rainbow that shifts over a smooth gradient from left to right (rather than distinct horizontal stripes, as in the traditional pride flag): this is symbolic of gender taking many forms and expressions, contrary to a binary, and forming a many varied continuum.
    2) In the center, would be the transgender symbol—the one which combines the female and male symbols into one—perhaps in white outlined in lavender. Lavender combines pink & blue. The white, as was used in the original flag, is all colors combined into one. This would be symbolic of coming together in unity as a community.

    After reading people’s responses to the original flag, I understand the symbolism behind the colors buuuuuut, I don’t think that symbolism is readily apparent. It’s too easily confused with a pink & blue, “all gender is on a binary” interpretation. It too readily plays into the hands of our adversaries who accuse us of upholding the gender binary and gender conformity.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.