Antigay Ammendment introduced in PA

December 10, 2005 ·

Two friends of mine have lost partners to death in the last year and a half. In each case they found that the legal protections that they set up to try and cover at least some of the benefits granted by marriage were inadequate. Both of my friends had to deal with legal and financial traumas in the wake of one of the most devastating losses that a person can experience.

We have few protections legally without marriage. To give a pointed example, a friend described to me her frustration in spending 2,500 dollars trying to set up arrangements so that she and her partner had at least some of the basic financial rights that a heterosexual married couple does. “And I could have more than this for twenty dollars if I could get a marriage license!” she had exclaimed as we sipped coffee discussing it.

The little, yet frustratingly difficult to achieve things that we can do now to try and claw into the exclusive privileges of a married couple for the sake of protecting someone that we love and have shared our life with may well be swept away courtesy of radical reactionaries in the Pennsylvania Legislature. Representative Daryl Metcalfe (R-Butler) and Senator Scott Boyd (R-Lancaster) have sought signatures for co-sponsors of bill to add an amendment to the Pennsylvania Constitution that would comprehensively invalidate any attempt to duplicate any type or form of the “rights” and protections that a heterosexual married couple share.

The reality of the situation is that if the bill passes, it is likely to be approved by the voters in a referendum. We are a tiny proportion of the population of the Commonwealth. The Amendment, packaged as a “protection” of marriage, will be sold to the public as just that, as it was in other states. Only afterwards will the reactionaries use it to end private and publicly funded domestic partner benefits, wills, joint checking accounts and other means that we currently use to try and provide for our loved ones, Oregon and Ohio being the most recent example of their objectives.

The Amendment will not simply block for decades our pursuit of further protections and recognition of our relationships; it will turn to ash any measures that we take financially on behalf of our loved ones now. It will leave medical decision making, power of attorney, property and financial resources vulnerable to legal challenges by blood kin despite stated intentions to have these things pass to the individual that we have loved so deeply as to pledge to spend our life with.

Pennsylvania began as an experiment in tolerance and freedom, the child of the thinking of individuals such as William Penn, James Logan and Margaret Fell. It was born out of a reaction to the destruction of human rights by Cromwell and the Roundheads in the name their twisted view of morality. Swept out of power, the intolerant beliefs and tyrannies of these tormentors that Penn feared so deeply as to inspire the fervent pursuit of Pennsylvania Liberty also lingered to cast them as the spiritual ancestors and inspiration of the reactionaries in America today.

If the Marriage Amendment passes, the experiment that is Pennsylvania as we know it will have ended, the dreams of tolerance will have crumbled to dust, and the spirits of Cromwell and the Roundheads will have arrived to lay waste to freedom of conscience and the individual.

Caillean Maureen McMahon
Pennsylvania Gay and Lesbian Alliance

In category:Opinion
Next Post

Rainbow Golden Globes

Considering the political climate, it's amazing that the Golden Globes nominated the following: BEST MOTION PICTURE – DRAMA BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN BEST PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS IN A MOTION PICTURE – DRAMA FELICITY HUFFMAN-TRANSAMERICA BEST PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS IN A…
Read
Previous Post

Reason 430430983098 Why I Want Surgery

"Although Facen had breasts and lived as a woman, the Sheriff's Department was treating her as a man because she had male genitalia, Lt. Tom Bennett said."
Read
Random Post

Separatists and Fundamentalists

As some of you know some Separatists recently colluded in a bid to have the United Nations remove trans protections based upon gender identity and expression. Dana Lane Taylor, Cathy Brennan and Elizabeth Hungerford happily sent the following letter to the United Nations Entity for…
Read
Random Post

TERF Appropriation of the Trans Day of Remembrance

Our friend Lee is back with another awesome critical commentary comic: On May 13, the TransAdvocate wrote about the appropriation of the Trans Day of Remembrance by Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminists (TERFs). Cathy Brennan, contributor to the Radfem2013 conference, has…
Read
Random Post

Some Transgender History

Read
Random Post

Gender Nation: Justice coming in two anti-trans murders

Gender Nation is a bi-weekly column by Gwendolyn Ann Smith, the founder of the Transgender Day of Remembrance, reviewing news affecting the trans, intersex, and genderqueer community. Justice coming in two anti-trans murders Vermont and Texas, as a pair of anti-transgender…
Read