What exactly is St Patrick’s Day as it is celebrated in the states?

March 4, 2006 ·

What exactly is St Patrick’s Day as it is celebrated in the states?

Per se; it is a celebration of “Irishness” though only a certain kind.
The music that will be playing in the bars, sung by irish tenors, will
by and large be American in origin, a sort of faux irish with absolutely
nothing to do with Irish culture.
You will not hear O’Carolan, a contemporary of Bach’s, played.
You will not hear any of the nation’s very accolplished folk performers.

Shamrocks will be everywhere. But where will be the elaborate designs
that were beauty rendered into gold and enamel that came from Ireland?
Where will one see the imaginative art, archetecture and creations of
Irish men and women of more mdern times.

We will see plenty of Barry Fitzgerald and Bing Crosby, but what station
or network will play “The Magdalen Sisters?”

American St Patrick’s Day remains a celebration of the oppressive dream
of Eamon de Valera and Archbishop McQuaid of an Ireland of
unquestioning, devout sheep. Women at home, or in the fields, men
working, marginally educated, prayer rather than women’s healthcare,
Catholics forbidden to seek the best education, a predatory clergy.

Many St Patrick’s Parades will enthrone a local prelate. Where were the
Bishops on Easter Monday in 1916 when brave men and women rose to fight
what they knew would be their last, hopeless battle? The same church
that will be honoured forbade honours being given to the first president
of Ireland, Douglas Hyde, a revolutionary. His unforgivable sin? He was
a protestant. The same church also condemned Parnell and crushed Irish
Secualr Nationalism and any hope of a united Ireland on “moral grounds,”
he had committed adultery, while their priests were committing rapine
upon the young women sentenced into the laundries.

Who on St Pat’s Day will remeber Connie Markiewicz kissing her gun as
she surrendered after commanding part of the Rising near the General
Post Office?

Who will remember Sir Roger Casement, the exposer of the congo slave
trade and the true father of independent Ireland who paid for his dream
with his life? A gay man, he certainly would not be welcome at the
American Celebrations now, he was a Protestant as well as homosexual.

Who will remember wild Maud Gonne, who relentlessly agitated for a
forcible resistance to British rule, who inspired men and motivated
women fo fight and to die? No Bishop will mention her, she was a

Patrick Pearse, commander and chief of the forces of the Rising, will be
remembered in the proclamations of the Irish Republic bearing his name
in many pubs. No one will mention that he was gay.

Who will remember Eva Booth-Gore, activist, poet and rebel? Were she
alive, she could not participate in a parade. She was a Lesbian.

Remove the shamrocks, remove the green, turn off the music and be honest
America. You are celebrating the Catholic Church and the nightmare that
it visited upon Ireland, de Valera and McQuaid’s Ireland, and Ireland
frankly can do without that kind of honour or attention. Hang Pictures
of the Pope, play Tantum Ergo…and when the Archbishop of New York
parades down the street, try and remember a predecessor of his who
stated that the Hunger, the Potato Famine that killed millions, was a
blessing since the migrating survivors would spread Catholicism to new

As for me, I will toast Eva, Connie, Maud, Douglas, Patrick, and Sir
Roger; and I will chuckle remembering that the Saint that is being
“honoured” that day is buried….in a Protestant Church in Ulster, in
the United Kingdom…..

Maureen McMahon

Depending upon her mood, Maureen McMahon is alternately elegant and
flamboyant, brilliant and ludicrous, visionary and dissipated. Perhaps
the only truism that can be applied to her is her aesthetic zeal.
Whatever Maureen does, she does with passion. Whatever Maureen truly is,
she is with passion.

In category:Opinion
Next Post

The Hypocricy of Catholic Charities

Boston Catholic Charities decision to close it's adoption services rather than comply with state guidelines that require them to consider all good people as equal when placing children is yet another reminder of the remorseless attitude of this Pope and…
Previous Post

Felicity Gets It!

There are so many negative stereotypes when it comes to transgender people, it's a beautiful thing when someone not only "gets it," but also stands up proudly and puts down those stereotypes. That's exactly what Felicity Huffman did when she…
Random Post

"So, what was Stonewall?"

In the wake of the President Obama's historic speech referencing Stonewall, NPR ran a piece asking and purporting to answer the question, "So, what was Stonewall?" The article calls upon Martin Duberman, now 82, to retell the story of Stonewall. Martin Duberman published the first history of…
Random Post

The Observer Screws Up

There are things one does not do in a national newspaper. One does not call Blacks "uppity ni**ers". One does not state as fact that Yids drink the blood of Christian children. And one does not publish articles like this one.…
Random Post

What is gender artifactualism?

This is the one in a series of blog posts in which I discuss some of the concepts and terminology that I forward in my writings, including my new book Excluded: Making Feminist and Queer Movements More Inclusive. So in Excluded, I introduce the…
Random Post

Improper Purpose

Massachusetts recently signed into law an anti-discrimination bill which adds gender identity to its protected classes in the areas of employment and housing only. Gender identity is defined as follows:    “Gender identity” shall mean a person's gender-related identity, appearance or…